(e-content developed by Prof. (Dr) N A Jarandikar)
Transformation and Transposition
These are the important terms from film studies. They are related to making a film based on a literary text. They are a further exploration of the idea of ‘adaptation’. The word ‘transformation’ originates from ‘to transform’. The dictionary meaning of ‘to transform’ is ‘to change completely’. The word ‘transposition’ originates from ‘to transpose’. The dictionary meaning of ‘to transpose’ is ‘to change from one position to another. In short, ‘transformation’ requires a complete change, whereas ‘transposition’ requires a moderate change.
Transformation:
It is a loose and creative adaptation. A filmmaker makes major changes in the original literary work. These major changes can be at multiple levels, such as changes in plot, changes in characters, changes in ending, etc. The technical term used for such changes is ‘cinematic liberty’. Many a time, s/he takes literary text as a starting point, and then goes on adding and editing the ideas as per the requirements. Usually, a filmmaker mentions the original literary text in the credits given either at the beginning or the end of the cinema. A filmmaker considers it as his moral responsibility. The main purpose of transformation is to interpret the original text for a new context.
The film ‘Angoor’ is a classic example of transformation. The film is based on a classic play, ‘Comedy of Errors’ by William Shakespeare. The filmmaker has kept the major plotline intact. But the motif of the characters, their names, and the setting are changed. There is an addition of songs too. The film ‘3 Idiots’ is also another example of transformation. The film is based on Chetan Bhagat’s novel ‘Five Point Someone’. But the filmmaker has used the novel just as a starting point. To make it dramatic and entertaining, the filmmaker has made significant changes in the original novel. The film ‘Dev D’ is the transformation of the novel ‘Devdas’, but the original literary text is not mentioned in the film’s credits.
Transposition:
It is a very close and faithful adaptation. A filmmaker makes moderate changes in the original literary work. Usually, the names of characters and, setting are kept intact. A slight modification and editing are done in the the case of plot. Too much liberty is avoided by the filmmaker. Due credit is given to the original literary text. The main purpose of transposition is to maintain and preserve the original literary text as it is.
The film ‘Train to Pakistan’ is a good example of transposition. The film is based on the novel by Khushwant Singh with the same title. Right from the title, everything has been faithfully retained in the film by the filmmaker. The Marathi film ‘Natrang’ is another example of transposition. The film is based on the novel with the same title by Anand Yadav.
* * * * *